Can’t decide between two gadgets? Pick a category, choose up to 3 products I have reviewed, and see price, rating, pros and cons, and specs side by side.

Compare products

1. Choose a category

2. Pick up to 3 products

2 of 3 selected

ProductEmporia Vue Gen 2Emporia Vue Gen 2Emporia
Discontinued
Shelly EM Gen3Shelly EM Gen3Shelly
My rating 4.0 4.6
Typical price$150–$200$65–$75
Best forBudget buyers who find the 16-sensor kit on sale and want real per-circuit numbers.Home Assistant users who want to meter one or two big circuits cheaply.
Pros
  • Circuit-level detail on up to 16 circuits plus both mains
  • Rated ±2% accuracy
  • Detailed app history, down to 1-second readings
  • UL listed
  • No subscription
  • About $70 with no hub or subscription
  • Works locally with Home Assistant and MQTT, plus Alexa and Google Home
  • Stores at least 10 days of 1-minute data on the device
  • Bluetooth for easy setup, plus Wi-Fi
  • 3-year warranty from Shelly US
Cons
  • Wi-Fi only (2.4GHz), with no Ethernet option
  • Only a 1-year warranty
  • Bulky clamps and loose connector plugs made the install slow, even for an electrician (Android Headlines)
  • Replaced by the Vue 3, which adds Ethernet for about the same price
  • Two channels at up to 80A each, so it cannot read 200A service mains
  • Only one clamp in the box; the second channel needs a clamp bought separately
  • Rated accuracy drops to ±5% below 1A (Shelly specs)
  • The app is less consumer-friendly than Emporia's (Smart Home Explorer)
Spec sourceManufacturer specs, checked against the Amazon listingManufacturer specs, checked against the Amazon listing
Circuit sensorsUp to 16 x 50A—
Mains sensors2 x 200A—
AccuracyRated ±2%Rated ±2% (2–50A)
Data interval1 second—
Connectivity2.4GHz Wi-Fi with external antennaWi-Fi, Bluetooth 4.2
Electrical systemsSingle-phase, split-phase 120/240V, three-phase up to 415Y/240V (no Delta)—
CertificationUL listed—
Size4.1 x 3.1 x 1.1 in1.46 x 1.65 x 0.63 in
Warranty1 year3 years (Shelly US)
Channels—2 (single-phase)
Clamp—1 x 50A included; 80A clamp optional
Max current—80A per channel
Voltage—110–240V AC, 50/60Hz
Relay output—Dry contact, 2A/240V max
Local logging—10 days at 1-minute intervals
Share this comparisonFacebookPinterest

Prices are typical ranges from my reviews and change often; check the retailer for the current price. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.