Can’t decide between two gadgets? Pick a category, choose up to 3 products I have reviewed, and see price, rating, pros and cons, and specs side by side.

Compare products

1. Choose a category

2. Pick up to 3 products

2 of 3 selected

ProductAeotec Home Energy Meter 8Aeotec Home Energy Meter 8AeotecShelly Pro EM-50 Energy MeterShelly Pro EM-50 Energy MeterShelly
My rating 4.2 4.3
Typical price$80–$100$110–$130
Best forHome Assistant and SmartThings users who want whole-home and solar readings that stay local.Tracking (and optionally switching) one or two big circuits like an EV charger, heat pump or solar feed.
Pros
  • Costs about $80 to $100, less than most whole-home monitors with solar tracking
  • Tracks both what you use and what solar panels send back to the grid
  • Works locally over Z-Wave, so readings don't depend on a cloud service
  • Z-Wave Long Range reaches a panel far from the hub
  • Splash-resistant housing (IP44)
  • Two 50A channels track two circuits, such as an EV charger and a heat pump
  • Built-in contact can drive a contactor to switch a big load on or off
  • Wi-Fi plus wired Ethernet for a steady connection
  • Tracks solar or battery circuits in both directions
  • Works locally with Home Assistant
Cons
  • Needs a Z-Wave hub; it has no app of its own and no Wi-Fi
  • Whole-home readings only, with no per-circuit detail
  • Only a 1-year warranty
  • SmartThings support is more limited than Home Assistant (Automate Life)
  • Two channels only, not a whole-home monitor for most houses
  • Clamps max out at 50A per channel
  • DIN-rail mounting usually needs a small enclosure in US homes
  • Contactor control needs a separate contactor and an electrician
Spec sourceManufacturer specs, checked against the Amazon listingManufacturer specs, checked against the Amazon listing
ModelZWA046 (US, 2 x 200A)Shelly Pro EM-50
Sensors2 x 200A clamps (whole-home, split-phase)—
AccuracyBetter than 99% above 0.05A (Aeotec)About 1%
SolarYes, separate consumption and production readings—
ConnectivityZ-Wave 800 with Long Range, S2 securityWi-Fi, LAN (Ethernet), Bluetooth
Hub neededYes (Home Assistant, SmartThings; Hubitat via a community driver)—
Power120V AC, wired into your electrical panel—
HousingIP44—
Operating temp-26°F to 104°F (Aeotec spec) · Amazon listing: 5°F to 140°F—
Warranty1 year—
Channels—2; two 50A split-core clamps (Amazon listing bullet) · Amazon listing 'Included components': 1 x 50A clamp
Measures—Consumption and production (bidirectional)
Switching—Built-in dry contact for an external contactor
Mounting—DIN rail
App—Shelly Smart Control; Home Assistant and MQTT supported
Share this comparisonFacebookPinterest

Prices are typical ranges from my reviews and change often; check the retailer for the current price. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.