Can’t decide between two gadgets? Pick a category, choose up to 3 products I have reviewed, and see price, rating, pros and cons, and specs side by side.

Compare products

1. Choose a category

2. Pick up to 3 products

2 of 3 selected

ProductAeotec Home Energy Meter 8Aeotec Home Energy Meter 8AeotecShelly Pro 3EM Energy MeterShelly Pro 3EM Energy MeterShelly
My rating 4.2 4.4
Typical price$80–$100$140–$170
Best forHome Assistant and SmartThings users who want whole-home and solar readings that stay local.Home Assistant users and solar owners who want accurate, local whole-home data.
Pros
  • Costs about $80 to $100, less than most whole-home monitors with solar tracking
  • Tracks both what you use and what solar panels send back to the grid
  • Works locally over Z-Wave, so readings don't depend on a cloud service
  • Z-Wave Long Range reaches a panel far from the hub
  • Splash-resistant housing (IP44)
  • Measures whole-home use and solar in both directions, with about 1% accuracy
  • Wi-Fi, wired LAN, Bluetooth and Matter, so it keeps working if Wi-Fi drops
  • Works locally with Home Assistant, no cloud needed
  • Three clamps cover both legs of US split-phase service plus a solar feed
  • Scripts and webhooks can switch other devices when usage spikes
Cons
  • Needs a Z-Wave hub; it has no app of its own and no Wi-Fi
  • Whole-home readings only, with no per-circuit detail
  • Only a 1-year warranty
  • SmartThings support is more limited than Home Assistant (Automate Life)
  • Mounts on a DIN rail, which most US panels lack, so you may need a small enclosure
  • Whole-home or a few circuits only, not 16 like the Emporia Vue 3
  • Setup is more technical than plug-and-play monitors
  • Needs an electrician to install
Spec sourceManufacturer specs, checked against the Amazon listingManufacturer specs, checked against the Amazon listing
ModelZWA046 (US, 2 x 200A)Shelly Pro 3EM 120A (v2)
Sensors2 x 200A clamps (whole-home, split-phase)3 x 120A split-core clamps
AccuracyBetter than 99% above 0.05A (Aeotec)About 1% (active energy)
SolarYes, separate consumption and production readings—
ConnectivityZ-Wave 800 with Long Range, S2 securityWi-Fi, LAN (Ethernet), Bluetooth, Matter
Hub neededYes (Home Assistant, SmartThings; Hubitat via a community driver)—
Power120V AC, wired into your electrical panel—
HousingIP44—
Operating temp-26°F to 104°F (Aeotec spec) · Amazon listing: 5°F to 140°F—
Warranty1 year—
Measures—Consumption and production (bidirectional)
Local control—Scripts, webhooks, Home Assistant, MQTT
Mounting—DIN rail
App—Shelly Smart Control (iOS, Android, web)
Share this comparisonFacebookPinterest

Prices are typical ranges from my reviews and change often; check the retailer for the current price. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.